Learning how to write a logic problem solution starts with noticing what your scratch work leaves out. A note like “blue can't be 1” may be enough while the clue is fresh in your mind. A reader needs to know which clue rules out position 1 and how it does so. In the Qualification Round, a useful goal is to make that reasoning visible without copying every guess or false start.
Consider this practice puzzle. Four cards, one blue, one red, one green, and one yellow, occupy positions 1 through 4 from left to right, with exactly one card in each position. Blue is immediately to the left of red. Green is somewhere to the left of blue. Yellow is not in position 4. Determine the only possible order.
On paper, the work might look like this:
BR together BR 1,2 no G BR 2,3 gives G B R Y x BR 3,4 gives G Y B R check yes
The notes lead to the right answer. They also rely on the writer remembering what “no G” means, why the cross appears beside one order, and how yellow ended up second in the surviving order. Those are not cosmetic problems. Each mark stands for a reason the reader needs in order to follow the argument.
First, identify the givens that drive the argument. “Immediately to the left” makes blue and red an ordered pair in adjacent positions. Keep the word “immediately” or replace it with something equally precise. If you write only “blue is left of red,” you have changed the clue: the weaker wording would allow cards between them.
Next, turn the list of trials into a list of cases. The blue and red pair can occupy positions 1 and 2, 2 and 3, or 3 and 4. Say why the list stops there: blue cannot be in position 4 because red needs a position immediately to its right. Once the reader sees that the cases cover every placement of the pair, crossing out two of them has a different force. You are no longer reporting that you found one arrangement. You are showing that no other placement of the pair can work.
Then replace each shorthand mark with its reason. “No G” does not mean the green card is missing. It means that if blue is first, there is no position to its left for green. The cross beside “G B R Y” needs two steps: green is forced into position 1, and then yellow is forced into position 4, where the puzzle says it cannot go. Notice the word then. Yellow is not forced into position 4 just because blue and red take the middle positions. It is forced there after green takes position 1.
Number the positions 1 through 4 from left to right. Since blue is immediately to the left of red, their positions must be 1 and 2, 2 and 3, or 3 and 4, with blue first in each pair.
If blue and red occupy positions 1 and 2, no position lies to the left of blue. That violates the clue about green.
If they occupy positions 2 and 3, green must be in position 1 because it is the only position to the left of blue. Yellow must then take the only unoccupied position, position 4. That violates the clue about yellow.
So blue and red must occupy positions 3 and 4. The remaining positions are 1 and 2. Since yellow is not in position 4, that clue does not distinguish between these remaining positions. Here, the green clue must be satisfied too.
Read the last paragraph carefully. It sounds like the argument is about to finish, but what does the green clue actually say? Green must be left of blue, which is in position 3. Both position 1 and position 2 are left of position 3. The scratch work picked one of them without a reason. In fact, the problem as stated does not have the only possible order it asks for.
To finish the solution, replace the unsupported choice with a check of both remaining arrangements:
With blue in position 3 and red in position 4, green and yellow can occupy positions 1 and 2 in either order. In both green, yellow, blue, red and yellow, green, blue, red, each card occurs once, blue is immediately to the left of red, green is to the left of blue, and yellow is not in position 4. These are the only two orders because the other placements of blue and red were ruled out. The clues do not determine a unique order.
Checking the scratch answer against the clues confirms that it works. It does not confirm that it is unique. To check a uniqueness claim, look for any choice the argument leaves open. Here, it leaves two cards in two slots. Swapping those cards is a quick way to test whether you proved that one of them had to come first or merely wrote it first.
When you use the training and practice problems, try a second pass on a solution you have already worked out. The same habit is useful when working on the first stage described in how the competition rounds work, the Qualification Round.
As a short follow-up exercise, change the yellow clue to “Yellow is immediately to the left of blue.” Find the step in the revised argument that now rules out one of the two surviving orders. Then reread the earlier cases: changing a given means their reasons need a fresh check too.
Do I need to copy every step from my scratch work?
No. Keep the deductions and cases that support your conclusion. Leave out abandoned guesses unless ruling them out is part of the argument.
How do I show that my answer is the only one?
Show that your answer fits every clue and that the reasoning rules out every alternative. If you split the problem into cases, explain why your cases cover all possibilities.
About the Global Logic and Reasoning Competition: an online logic and reasoning competition for high school students from around the world. How the rounds work