Blog › Logic And Reasoning Explained
In these valid vs sound argument examples, two arguments reach the same true conclusion: 12 is even. Both use the same pattern, but only one is sound. The difference is not in how the conclusion is drawn. It is in what each argument asks you to accept before you draw it.
| Part | Argument A | Argument B |
|---|---|---|
| Premise 1 | Every multiple of 4 is even. | Every multiple of 3 is even. |
| Premise 2 | 12 is a multiple of 4. | 12 is a multiple of 3. |
| Conclusion | 12 is even. | 12 is even. |
A premise is a claim offered in support of a conclusion. In both arguments, the first premise gives a rule about an entire group, and the second puts 12 in that group. If both premises were true, the rule would apply to 12. So both arguments are valid: there is no way for all their premises to be true and their conclusion false.
Only Argument A is sound. A sound deductive argument is valid and has all true premises. Every multiple of 4 is even because multiplying a whole number by 4 gives twice another whole number, and 12 is 4 times 3. In Argument B, the second premise is true, but the first is false: 9 is a multiple of 3 and is odd. Knowing that 12 is even does not repair the false rule used to get there.
To test validity, temporarily grant the premises. This does not mean agreeing with them. It means asking what else you would have to accept if they were true. In Argument B, for instance, if every multiple of 3 were even and 12 were a multiple of 3, then denying that 12 is even would conflict with what you just granted.
You can see the shared structure by replacing the subject matter with placeholders:
Draw a large circle for group B and a smaller circle entirely inside it for group A. Put a dot labeled x inside A. There is nowhere to put that dot outside B without breaking one of the premises. The drawing shows why the reasoning works. It does not tell you whether multiples of 3 really belong inside the group of even numbers. That is a separate check.
In a logic exercise, separate those checks on paper. Write “The conclusion follows if both premises are true” next to the inference. Then mark each premise true, false, or not yet verified. If you are turning your notes into a full explanation, our guide on writing a logic problem solution from rough work can help you make each step visible.
Now reverse the direction of Argument A. Start with “Every multiple of 4 is even” and “12 is even.” Then conclude “12 is a multiple of 4.” Both premises are true, and the conclusion is true too. But the conclusion does not follow from those premises.
To see the gap, use the same pattern with 6. Every multiple of 4 is even, and 6 is even, but 6 is not a multiple of 4. The rule lets you move from being a multiple of 4 to being even, not the other way around. In the circle drawing, a dot in the large circle could be outside the smaller one.
Notice what the two odd-looking results tell you. In Argument B, finding the odd multiple 9 disproves a premise, not the link between the premises and the conclusion. In the reversed argument, using 6 exposes a problem with the link. These are different objections. Saying only “that argument is wrong” leaves the reader guessing which one you mean.
Outside a math exercise, the first step can be the easier one. Suppose someone says, “Every book on this cart has already been checked in. This atlas is on the cart. So the atlas has already been checked in.” The inference is valid. Whether it is sound depends on what actually happened at the library.
Start with the exact wording. “Every book on this cart has already been checked in” makes a claim about all the books there. A sign that reads “Checked-in books only” gives a rule for using the cart, but it does not prove that everyone followed the rule. A current check-in record could help verify the claim about the atlas. It would not, by itself, verify the claim about every other book on the cart.
If the record confirms that the atlas was checked in, you have independent evidence for the conclusion. If you then discover that a novel on the same cart was not checked in, the argument is still valid but unsound. If you cannot verify the first premise either way, say you have not established soundness. An unverified premise is not automatically a false one.
Take Argument A and replace just its second premise. Leave the rule and conclusion untouched: “Every multiple of 4 is even. 12 is a multiple of 8. Therefore, 12 is even.” Before checking the arithmetic, ask whether the stated rule covers the group named in the second premise. If you think a step is missing, write it down before reading on.
The missing step is that every multiple of 8 is a multiple of 4. With that extra premise, the conclusion follows: the reasoning now links multiples of 8 to multiples of 4 and then to even numbers. But adding a true premise to fix the link does not make the argument sound. The claim that 12 is a multiple of 8 is still false.
For another practice item, use an example from the GLRC training and practice problems and label what the problem gives you and what you infer. If your inference needs a rule you have not written down, add it explicitly. Then check whether the problem gives you that rule or whether you need to justify it yourself.
Can a valid argument have a false conclusion?
Yes, but at least one premise must be false. A valid argument cannot have all true premises and a false conclusion.
Does a true conclusion make an argument sound?
No. The conclusion must follow from the premises, and every premise must be true.
What if I cannot verify a premise?
You can still test whether the conclusion follows. Until you establish that all the premises are true, you have not established that the argument is sound.
About the Global Logic and Reasoning Competition: an online logic and reasoning competition for high school students from around the world. How the rounds work